The Noble Combi handles space heating and hot water from one cabinet; the Noble Boiler heats only, paired with a separate tank for domestic hot water.
Tell us what you need—we’ll call you back fast.
Quick answer
The core difference is that the Lochinvar Noble Combi is a condensing fire-tube combi boiler, meaning it provides both space heating and on-demand domestic hot water from a single unit, while the Lochinvar Noble Boiler is a condensing fire-tube heat-only boiler that handles space heating alone and needs a separate tank, typically an indirect tank, for domestic hot water. The right choice comes down to how much simultaneous hot water your household actually needs and how much mechanical room space you have, not which product is generally better.
Need a licensed gas fitter for your gas boiler? Call CANRO at (604) 359-1081 — residential natural-gas heating and hot water across Metro Vancouver since 1999.
Both units share the same basic technology: a condensing fire-tube design, which is a heat exchanger configuration that circulates hot combustion gases through tubes surrounded by system water, extracting extra efficiency by cooling the exhaust enough to condense it. Where they differ is scope. The Noble Combi packages a domestic hot water plate exchanger and an internal diverter valve into the same cabinet, so opening a tap redirects the unit's output toward heating water on demand instead of the space heating loop, then switches back once the tap closes.
The Noble Boiler does one job: it heats the hydronic loop for your radiators, baseboards, or radiant floor. It has no built-in path to domestic hot water at all. A home running a Noble Boiler gets its hot water from somewhere else entirely, most commonly a separate indirect tank that draws heat from the boiler's loop, or from an existing standalone gas water heater kept independent of the boiler system.
| Aspect | Noble Combi | Noble Boiler + separate tank |
|---|---|---|
| Hot water source | Built-in plate exchanger, on demand | Separate indirect tank or standalone water heater |
| Simultaneous fixture demand | Limited by the combi's instantaneous capacity | Limited by tank volume, generally handles simultaneous draws better |
| Mechanical room footprint | Smaller, one cabinet | Larger, boiler plus tank |
| Recovery after heavy use | Instant recovery since it is on-demand | Depends on tank size and recovery rate |
| Suite or laneway house hot water | Shares the same combi capacity as the main house | Can be sized or supplemented independently |
Neither column is universally better. A combi's instant, unlimited-duration hot water is genuinely convenient for a household that rarely runs two showers and a dishwasher at the exact same moment. A tank-based setup handles that overlapping demand more comfortably because it draws down stored volume rather than instantaneous capacity, at the cost of needing more physical space.
A Noble Combi tends to make sense for a typical single-family home with moderate hot water use and a mechanical closet where space is at a premium, which describes a good number of Metro Vancouver homes with basement mechanical rooms shared with laundry and storage. It also appeals to homeowners who like the idea of never running out of hot water during a long shower, since the domestic hot water side is not limited by tank volume the way an indirect setup is.
A Noble Boiler paired with a dedicated indirect tank tends to fit better in larger households, homes with a basement suite or laneway house drawing from the same system, or households that regularly run multiple hot water fixtures at once, several bathrooms during a busy morning, for example. The separate tank buffers that simultaneous demand in a way a combi's instantaneous output is not designed to match. It is also worth considering for homes doing a major renovation where mechanical room space is not as tight a constraint.
Neither the Noble Combi nor the Noble Boiler is the objectively correct choice; the honest answer depends on how your specific household actually uses hot water day to day, which is exactly the conversation CANRO has with a homeowner before recommending either configuration.
A Noble Combi has one additional component a Noble Boiler does not: the internal diverter valve that switches flow between heating and hot water modes. That valve is a wear item specific to combi configurations and is one of the more common service calls we see on combi units generally, not specific to this series. A Noble Boiler paired with an indirect tank instead has a separate tank to maintain, including its own anode and periodic flush schedule, which is a different maintenance rhythm rather than a simpler or more complex one overall.
Both units use the same condensing fire-tube heat exchanger design at their core, so annual service, checking combustion, venting, condensate handling, and safety controls, looks similar between them; the combi visit simply adds a check of the domestic hot water plate exchanger and diverter valve that a heat-only boiler visit does not need.
On installation cost, a combi and a heat-only boiler with a separate indirect tank can land in a similar overall range once the tank and its piping are factored in, since you are paying for either an integrated combi mechanism or a standalone tank and its connections. CANRO's certified technicians can walk through both configurations with actual numbers for your specific home rather than a generic comparison, since venting, gas sizing, and mechanical room layout affect each configuration differently.
Safety note
Both the Noble Combi and the Noble Boiler are gas-fired appliances, and installation, conversion between configurations, or repair work on either must be performed by a Technical Safety BC licensed gas fitter. If you ever smell gas near either type of system, leave the home and call FortisBC at 1-800-663-9911.
It is possible in some homes but is a significant project involving new piping, a diverter valve, and a plate exchanger rather than a simple swap, so it needs its own in-home assessment rather than a general yes or no answer.
A combi does not run out of stored hot water the way a tank does, but its instantaneous output has a practical limit, so multiple simultaneous heavy draws can still stretch it thinner than a well-sized tank system would handle.
Both use the same condensing fire-tube technology at their core, so efficiency differences between them come down more to how well each is sized and installed for the specific home than to the combi versus heat-only distinction itself.
A Noble Boiler paired with a separate indirect tank generally needs more floor space than a Noble Combi, which packages everything into one cabinet, a meaningful factor in a tight basement mechanical room.
It depends on whether the laneway house draws hot water from the same system as the main house; if so, a heat-only boiler with an appropriately sized tank often handles that added simultaneous demand more comfortably than stretching a single combi across two households.
Typical repair costs fall in similar ranges since both share the same core heat exchanger technology; the combi carries the added possibility of a diverter valve repair that a heat-only boiler setup does not have, while a heat-only setup carries its own tank-related maintenance instead.
Family-run, TSBC-licensed (gas LGA0043870 · boiler LBP0046450), serving Metro Vancouver homes since 1999. Residential, natural gas only.
Call (604) 359-1081 Email info@canroheat.ca“Canro does an amazing job! Super professional and skilled with everything—boilers, furnaces, and AC. Always a pleasure working with them!”
“Five stars for Canro. We needed a replacement of a 30-year-old boiler. A new high-efficiency unit was installed—clean, professional work.”
“I can’t speak highly enough about George, who was recommended for a boiler service call for my parents’ home. George is excellent.”
25+ years keeping Metro Vancouver homes comfortable. Honest advice, upfront pricing, work that lasts.